Winnipeg Jewish Review  
Site Search:
Home  |  Archives  |  Contact Us
Features Local Israel Next Generation Arts/Op-Eds Editorial/Letters Links Obituary/In Memoriam

Elliot Leven

Dr. Catherine Chatterley

The strange case of Jennifer Peto

Op-Ed by Elliot Leven followed by Op-Ed by Dr. Catherine Chatterley followed by letter by Peto's sister

By Elliot Leven, and separate Op-Ed by Dr. Catherine Chatterley, March 2,2010

 [The following is an Op-Ed by  Elliot Leven, a Winnipeg lawyer.Follwong this Op-Ed there is another Op-Ed regarding Jennifer Peto's thesis by Dr. Catherine Chatterley]

A University of Toronto Sociology Master’s thesis called “The Victimhood of the Powerful: White Jews, Zionism and the Racism of Hegemonic Holocaust Education” does not make for light reading.  However, I can report that I just finished reading this tome, authored by a Toronto, Jewish lesbian named Jennifer Peto.  The thesis attacks the March of the Living and the March of Remembrance and Hope, based on a review of their websites.

 Ms. Peto is an organizer for the Coalition Against Israeli Apartheid.  In her thesis, she brags about how she was arrested by the Toronto police on January 7, 2009 for participating in an eight-person occupation of the Israeli consulate.  Though proud of her arrest, she confesses that she was disappointed that it did not get more media attention.  Ms. Peto also mentions in her thesis that she helped to organize Israeli Apartheid Week in 2009.

The thesis made the news in December when two Members of the Ontario Provincial Parliament denounced Ms. Peto in the legislature.  One called the thesis “shockingly anti-Semitic”.  The other was “disgusted”.  Unfortunately, neither actually read it.

Perhaps the most interesting part of the thesis is Ms. Peto’s reminiscence of how, at age 15, she was kicked out of Jewish History class for fighting with her narrow-minded teacher about Baruch Goldstein. Goldstein was the lunatic who murdered 50 Muslims at the Tomb of the Patriarchs in Hebron in 1994.  

According to Ms. Peto, her misguided teacher referred to Goldstein in a positive way and, when Ms. Peto objected, the teacher sent her to the principal’s office where she was reprimanded. Ms. Peto adds that, at the Orthodox schools she attended, she was always getting in trouble for her unorthodox views.

I am not sure why Ms. Peto included the Baruch Goldstein anecdote in her Masters thesis.  If I were a psychoanalyst, I might speculate that the thesis is Peto’s revenge on all the narrow-minded teachers who ever sent her to the office. Certainly, if not for the hilarious academic jargon (the word “hegemonic” has not been used so often since Chairman Mao died), the thesis might well have been written by an angry 15-year-old, looking for revenge against her Orthodox teachers.

The attacks on the thesis by Ontario politicians became a minor side-show.  These attacks attracted coverage by the National Post and Macleans.  Defenders of Ms. Peto waved the banner of “academic freedom” in her defence.

In any event, this is what the thesis says. It starts with the observation that, in North America today, Jews are “white” (i.e. relatively advantaged).  Though North American anti-Semitism exists, it has declined a lot, and is now fairly minor.  Ms. Peto digresses to note that white Jews in the southern United States and in apartheid-era South Africa were also advantaged. She mentions in passing that some white Jews fought on the Confederate side in the American Civil War.

Ms. Peto then turns to Israel, which she labels an “Apartheid State”.  She feels that Zionism is a “racist, imperialist ideology”.  She believes that, in 1948, Israel “ethnically cleansed” over 750,000 Palestinians.

Next she focuses on the March of the Living (an annual trip to Poland and Israel for Jewish youth), and the March of Remembrance and Hope (an annual trip to Poland for non-Jewish youth).  Her only source of information about the marches was their official websites.  She did not speak to a single participant in either march.  She attacks the “Holocaust industry”.  Jews cunningly emphasize the Holocaust so that they can posture as victims, as opposed to the “white” group that they really are. She feels that both marches serve to strengthen Israeli apartheid.

[The following is an op-ed by Elliot Leven and separate Op-Ed by Dr Catherine Chatterley

Ms. Peto mentions gay rights, and notes that Zionists in recent years have begun to talk about Israel’s tolerance of gays and lesbians.  She comments: “Like women’s rights, gay rights can be deployed as a justification for imperial wars against nations that do not respect human rights.”  She does not say a word about the state of gay rights in the Arab world.

Ms. Peto concludes: “Those of us committed both to preserving the integrity of Holocaust education and to fighting against racism and imperialism, must challenge hegemonic, Zionist Holocaust education that works to defend Israeli Apartheid and to further entrench the white privilege of Jews in the West.”  She offers no practical suggestions for solving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Ms. Peto’s thesis raises many issues.  Firstly, the Ontario politicians who attacked it without reading it were fools.  Secondly, of course, students and professors (and journalists) should have the academic freedom to criticize Israel for its shortcomings.  I regularly criticize Israel in these pages for such things as its West Bank settlement policies. Israel, like all nations, has its flaws.

Most importantly, the thesis is poorly written.  The idea of analysing a program based only on an official website is so ludicrous that I can’t believe Ms. Peto and her thesis advisor ever entertained the thought.  Websites are often superficial. Official websites are at best one piece of information among many.  Perhaps an essay for a marketing course might focus entirely on a website.  But a Sociology Masters thesis? 

As for Ms. Peto’s arguments, there is a tiny kernel of truth in what she says.  But, like an angry 15-year-old, she overplays her hand.  Yes, North American Jews have suffered less than other minority groups such as African Americans.  Yes, North American anti-Semitism is much less pervasive than it used to be.  Yes, Israel has shortcomings, and some Diaspora Jews are too timid about discussing them.  Yes, we sometimes put a bit too much emphasis on the Holocaust. Yes, the March of the Living does include a Zionist message.

If Ms. Peto had stuck to these facts, she might have written a very thoughtful thesis. Unfortunately, “thoughtful” is not Ms. Peto’s style.  She never uses an objective statement when overblown rhetoric will do.  The thought that human beings often have mixed motives never crosses her mind. The idea that the organizers and participants in the two marches might feel genuine sorrow about the Holocaust and might find the marches a heartfelt way to remember its victims, never occurs to her.  

The historical question of whether millions of lives might have been saved if a tiny little State of Israel had existed in the Tel Aviv area in 1933, is not one which Ms. Peto cares to think about.

The issue of whether modern Israel might be a mixture of positive and negative qualities (e.g. a genuine respect for gay rights, but a set of unjust policies in the West Bank) does not fit into Ms. Peto’s black-and-white narrative.

Pity.  Maybe someone will write a thoughtful Masters thesis about the ways Canadian Jews think about the Holocaust.  But that someone is not likely to be Jennifer P

<<Previous Article       Next Article >>
Subscribe to the Winnipeg Jewish Review
  • Jewish Federation of Winnipeg
  • Saper Agencies
  • Joyce Rykiss
  • CHW
  • Nic Curry
  • Blair Yakimoski
  • Commercial Pool
  • Danita and Michel Aziza and Family
  • GTP
  • Western Scrap Metals
  • Jim Muir
  • Eddie's Gravel Supply Ltd.
  • Sveinson Construction
  • The Home Store
  • John Bucklaschuk
  • Tyler Bucklaschuk
  • John Wishnowski
  • Stringer Rentals & Power Products
  • JLS Construction
  • European Shoe Shop
  • Roseman
  • Dr. Ali Raizman
  • Maric Homes
  • Artista Homes
  • Southwynn Homes
  • Tradesman Mechanical
  • Munroe Pharmacy
  • Myers LLP
  • Imperial Soap
  • Mobile Denture Services
  • Ron Zimmerman
  • Cliff Graydon
  • Steven Fletcher
  • Winnipeg Drapery
  • Bridges for Peace
  • HUB
  • Dimensions Insurance
  • Ingrid Bennett
  • Chochy's
  • Interlake Service
  • Hugh's Electric
  • Lakeside Roofing
  • KC Enterprises
  • Gulay Plumbing
  • Trevor Arnason Plumbing
  • Chisick Family
  • Accurate Lawn & Garden
  • Dr. Gary Levine
  • Fetching Style
  • Thorvaldson Care
  • Royal Le Page
  • Pizzeria Gusto
  • Total Lighting Sales
  • Erickson Motors Ltd.
  • Shoppers Drug Mart
  • Nikos
  • Sarel Canada
  • Santa Lucia Pizza
  • Center for Near East Policy Research
  • Roofco Winnipeg Roofing
  • Center for Near East Policy Research
  • Nachum Bedein
Rhonda Spivak, Editor

Publisher: Spivak's Jewish Review Ltd.

Opinions expressed in letters to the editor or articles by contributing writers are not necessarily endorsed by Winnipeg Jewish Review.